By Mike McIntyre
Monday night marked an entertaining evening of tennis action at the historic Madison Square Garden in New York City. In a unique and fast-paced format, Tie Break Tens took over the multi-sport venue and offered-up the Williams sisters to an adoring crowd. It was Ukrainian Elina Svitolina however, the No. 4 player in the world, who stole the show as she dismantled her three opponents en route to the championship title. Here's a look at my ten thoughts from Tie Break Tens as we wrap-up from the Big Apple.
1) Elina Svitolina will win a Grand Slam
Sure it was only an exhibition event, but you wouldn't have known that from watching Svitolina both on and off the court Monday night. The hard hitting 23 year old showed no mercy to opponents Venus Williams, CoCo Vandeweghe and Shuai Zhang and took them out by a collective score of 30-6. Even when Svitolina tried to be nice - on an underhanded serve while leading Vandeweghe 9-0 - she just couldn't pull it off and won the point. While some have criticized the Ukrainian for her failures on the Grand Slam stage, her resolve and continually improving game will one day lead her to the very top of the women's game. While some of her opponents were hamming-it-up with the crowd last night, on their cell phones or catching up with one another, Svitolina remained as focused as if she was preparing for a Grand Slam final. Such maturity and determination will certainly serve her well once she does reach that stage of a major.
2) Tennis works just fine in alternative formats
My apologies to all the tennis purists out there, but the action-packed, no-mercy design of Tie Break Tens is appealing and it delivers. Some of the matches were over in a hurry (see Svitolina d. Vandeweghe 10-0 as proof) but most were competitive and entertaining at the same time. This was not a "practice your tweener" type of event. While CoCo had to use some humor with the crowd to deflect from the beating she endured, the competitors all seemed interested in playing their best tennis. Plus watching Serena Williams court-side on a stationary bike while scouting-out her opponents was pretty unique to say the least.
3) The Williams sisters are still the biggest draw in women's tennis
Don't get me wrong - I love the depth that has emerged on the WTA Tour over the past few years. That being said, to see Serena and Venus Williams competing on court at the ages of 36 and 37 respectively is something we should all be so thankful for. They don't owe us this but continue to compete around the world - with six month old daughter in tow in Serena's case - because they love the sport so much. The reaction from Team USA's women's hockey team to meeting with Serena at the end of the evening pretty much summed-up the immense and undiminished star power that she and her sister still clearly possess.
4) CoCo Vandeweghe is entertaining
Like her or not, Coco was the only player last night trying to work the MSG crowd into a frenzy. At times it seemed like a younger, female version of Jimmy Connors trying to get the fans to liven it up and enjoy the moment. She has a fun-loving personality that comes across when talking in person. When we met prior to the start of play for a one-on-one she said I was lucky that she wasn't yet "hangry" while she postponed her pre-match meal. CoCo is a fiery personality to be sure and time will tell if she is able to harness that in a positive manner that will allow the 26 year old to deliver on her large potential.
5) Retirement is not the end of one's relationship with tennis
Including retired players in a competitive event will always be a risk. In the case of Daniela Hantuchova, things worked out just fine. The mix in styles between her and opponent CoCo Vandeweghe offered some entertaining variety for the crowd. Though she went down in her opening tiebreak, Hantuchova clearly enjoyed being back on a tennis court. The Slovak had an impressive 6-3 lead and could have likely closed it out had it been a tiebreak of the usual variety. She clearly had a game plan and that was to make Vandeweghe work for it. Five points in and we had already witnessed two drop shots from Hantuchova who cleverly used her experience to gain the early advantage. When CoCo yelled out, "Not again!" on the second one, you could tell that the plan was a solid one from the 34 year old who retired from competitive play last year. When I asked Hantuchova if she might follow the comebacks of Bartoli and Serena, she shouted, "No!" faster than I expected. The former World No. 5 is enjoying having a steady home-base to occupy on a regular basis and doesn't miss the hectic pace of life on the tour one bit. She was still very happy to play in the Tie Break Tens format and said future exhibition style matches would likely happen for her.
6) Mingling with other tennis fans is always fun
If you like watching tennis then chances are you also like talking about tennis. Part of the appeal of attending events like Tie Break Tens is catching-up with old tennis acquaintances or making new ones. Seeing Elina Svitolina's No. 1 fan Celeste again Monday night is a good example. I hadn't seen her since the Rogers Cup last summer but with Elina playing "a mere" 7 hour bus ride away from her home in Montreal, I was not one bit surprised she was present at MSG. Decked-out in blue and yellow (of course) and proudly waving her Ukrainian flag alongside her almost-as-enthusiastic mother, it is fans like these who make the sport what it is.
7) Serena Williams is going to struggle at the start of her comeback
After all she has been through these past six months it is truly amazing that Serena Williams is ready to compete at the highest level in her sport, but that's just what she is about to do in Indian Wells and Miami. Her physical fitness needs more time to return to what it once was and that is understandable but still needs to be said. While her serve showed moments of its usual brilliance, the foot speed and stamina have a long way to go. In short, I wouldn't place lofty expectations on the greatest tennis player of all-time (male or female) until she has had a few crash-and-burn events to get back into top gear. After that - hey, this is Serena we're talking about - anything can happen and likely will.
8) Marion Bartoli is going to struggle more at the start of her comeback
The 32 year old Frenchwoman has a long way to go before she is going to be competitive again on the WTA Tour. Kudos to her after all of the physical hardships she has endured over the past few years. It is unimaginable what the psychological and physical effects of her dangerous weight fluctuations must have been like to endure. That being said, her movement was quite suspect as she played Serena Williams last night and she seemed winded after a mere four points of play. If she's not ready for a super tiebreak to ten points, how is she going to survive a best-of-three match with women who have been playing day-in, day-out during her nearly five year absence from competition? Great to see the former Wimbledon champion back at it but I hope her expectations are realistic all things being said.
9) Find the right people
No offence to Mardy Fish, but being an MC is perhaps not the best option for his post-tennis career. The soft-spoken American was co-hosting alongside Hannah Storm but never seemed comfortable throughout the evening and lacked the pump-up ability required when speaking in front of the Madison Square Garden crowd.
The most ill-suited performance of the night goes to the chair umpire however who seriously bungled-up the late moments of the Serena vs Zhang semifinal. There was a moment where Serena had to discourage him several times to avoid re-playing a point that her opponent had successfully earned. He seemed very unsure of when playing a let was the right call to make and had Serena re-play a first serve that video review had shown was quite clearly an un-returnable bomb. Things got kind of awkward for a few minutes but Serena was gracious when it was all said and done.
10) Madison Square Garden is a cool place to watch tennis.
While the upper-bowl was closed and there were sections in the lower-bowl that had multiple empty seats, catching competitive tennis at this NYC landmark is always something special. Last night was immensely more action-packed then when I saw an aging Pete Sampras and Andre Agassi play each other back in 2011 years after both had packed it in. The venue is iconic and all of the players remarked how it meant something special to them to say they have now competed there. Surely we will see competitive tennis at the Garden again sometime in the future. When we do, I'll make a point of being there to enjoy it as I did Monday night.